Week 9: Makerspace!

When I first started my search for my article, I already knew the type of article I wanted to research. I know what makerspaces are and how fun they are, but I really wanted to know what students get out of them and ways to incorporate more than just “here’s the station, have fun!” type makerspace. The article entitled Problem Scoping: Design Thinking & Close Reading Makerspaces in the School Library by Megan Blakemore really helped me understand the benefits. Here are the three takeaways and which AASL Common Beliefs they fall under.

  1. “In the makerspace, before building students might write proposals. Students can also write reflections on the process or write their own instructional pieces” (Blakemore, 2018, p. 67). I always thought of makerspaces as being just a “hands on” learning tool, but I never thought of incorporating writing proposals BEFORE the activity. That is a great idea! This fits under AASL Common Belief #3: Learners should be prepared for college, career, and life (AASL, 2017). This fits here because in life, students may have a job where they have to write this type of writing, and it is extremely important to teach students to reflect on their work. This reflection step is the only way they can grow, and not enough students take the time to do this crucial life skill.
  2. “Connecting making and literacy has the potential for inviting students to engage with the text in new and deeper ways. Effective problem scoping from a literary work asks students to dig more deeply into the text to find relevant details” (Blakemore, 2018, p. 68). I also never thought of using a makerspace activity to relate to a book students are reading. Blakemore goes into detail in this article about how she reads the elementary school students a book such as The Young Man and The Sea, and their challenge is to make a boat for the main character (2018, p. 68). This way, they are connecting the book to the activity: it gives them a purpose and makes it fun and relatable. This relates to AASL Common Belief #4: Reading is the core of personal and academic competency. Under the description of this common belief, it it says: “School librarians curate current digital and print materials and technology to provide access to high-quality reading materials that encourage learners, educators, and families to become lifelong learners and readers” (AASL, 2017). I feel like this speaks for itself: the students are reading to encourage learning.
  3. “Rather than simply recreating something they have seen, when students complete the full design process they come up with novel ideas. Moreover, they can articulate how their invention solves the problem, thus demonstrating their problem-solving skills” (Blakemore, 2018, p. 69). I love the problem-solving part of this quote. Students need to know how to problem solve. This is an important life skill and this relates to AASL Common Belief #5: “Intellectual freedom is every learner’s right” (AASL, 2017). By allowing them to problem-solve on their own and figure out the solution to the character’s problem, they have the freedom to learn how they want.

I have learned through this article that makerspace is more than just building at random; it’s using multiple steps such as brainstorming, designing, building, testing and showcasing, aka problem scoping (Blakemore, 2018, p.67) to learn. I love the idea of incorporating literature into the makerspace activity; it’s like killing two birds with one stone!

References:

Blakemore, M. (2018). Problem scoping: design thinking & close reading makerspaces in the school library. Knowledge Quest,46(4), 66-69. Retrieved from http://eds.b.ebscohost.com.proxy.lib.odu.edu/ehost/detail/detail?vid=9&sid=ce704a0e-9502-430e-9f83-fb6af3f6c067@pdc-v-sessmgr02&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZSZzY29wZT1zaXRl#db=llf&AN=128199635

Common beliefs. (2017). Retrieved from https://standards.aasl.org/beliefs/

6 thoughts on “Week 9: Makerspace!”

  1. I love this quote you pulled out of your chosen article
    “Rather than simply recreating something they have seen, when students complete the full design process they come up with novel ideas. Moreover, they can articulate how their invention solves the problem, thus demonstrating their problem-solving skills”
    I think an important part of maker spaces is that they aren’t shown how to do something, but they are given enough tools to figure it out on their own. I wish we had maker spaces growing up. They are truly amazing!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Wow! Thanks for sharing your insights from this article. I totally agree that incorporating literacy into makerspace is an ingenious idea! I Adding a writing component even as a reflection, could be powerful for students because it instills mindfulness. This is certainly doable at the elementary level and would be even richer in upper school levels.
      I also like how you shared about connecting a makerspace activity with a book reading. This would be a great way for students to share their ideas about characters or setting from a fictional novel and then compare them to other thoughts. Everyone thinks so differently, and this would really help celebrate uniqueness and innovation.
      Thanks for opening my eyes to whole new possibilities!
      – Lauren B.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I love the idea of having students present a proposal before they build. I think this was a great choice of an article. I also, like Amanda, love the “Rather than simply recreating something they have seen, when students complete the full design process they come up with novel ideas. Moreover, they can articulate how their invention solves the problem, thus demonstrating their problem-solving skills”. I think that students need to be given that opportunity in class as well. I know that a lot of times, it’s easier said than done. But we have created a society that doesn’t know how to problem-solve or use critical thinking skills. I wish, even for my ownself, that we would find a way not just through maker spaces to help students develop these skills. They are so vital to life!

    Like

  3. I love the concept of fostering literacy through reading and writing within makerspaces. The idea of creating something based on what you are reading really appeals to me. It also occurs to me that even writing down the steps you are going to take or have taken to create something will help students better understand sequencing and procedures (two difficult skills for many students even at the middle school level.

    Like

  4. Ooohhh! I love your take-aways from this article. I have led a STREAM program at my school in the past and have done some engaging engineering design challenges. I love the idea of tying some literature into that challenge. This could really step up your maker space game. But writing about your idea from a maker space project, now that’s a game changer! Great insights!

    Like

  5. I do think that we should evaluate students on what they are able to do and not if they performed the task correctly. Some students will have a different method to get to the same goal. Some students may not meet the goal but their understanding may have increased while engaged in the task and can relate that to the instructor. I love maker spaces and I love the article that you have shared.

    Like

Leave a reply to lwhetsel Cancel reply